44 State Attorneys General Challenge CFTC’s Prediction Market Rules

44 State Attorneys General Challenge CFTC’s Prediction Market Rules


CFTC proposes expanding swaps definition to include sports and election contracts, aiming federal oversight.

Interim rule distinguishes house‑backed casino games from peer‑to‑peer event markets, classifying the former as gambling swaps.

Platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket claim financial‑contract status to bypass state gambling restrictions, citing CFTC jurisdiction.

The fight over who controls prediction markets in the United States has reached another stage, as a bipartisan group of 44 attorneys general challenges two rulemakings by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). 

According to an official release dated November 20, the coalition argues that the rules could give the federal agency control over sports and election betting, taking away powers traditionally held by individual states. 

The coalition, co-led by New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, submitted objections to the CFTC this week. It wants the regulator to reconsider its approach, arguing that platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket should not be allowed to avoid state gambling laws by describing their betting products as financial contracts.

While the CFTC is seeking to establish federal control over these platforms, several state governments believe they should have the final say over gambling activities within their borders.

Why the CFTC and states disagree

Prediction markets allow people to put money on the outcome of future events. These can include sports matches, elections, economic developments, and other real-world events. For example, a user could buy a contract based on whether a particular football team will win a match. If the event happens as predicted, the contract pays out according to its terms. Users can also trade these contracts based on their expectations of what will happen.

Platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket argue that they operate as financial contract markets under federal rules. This position allows them to claim that their activities fall under the CFTC rather than traditional state gambling laws.

However, state regulators disagree, particularly when it comes to sports betting. They argue that allowing people to put money on game results is still gambling, regardless of whether the platform calls the activity event trading or a financial contract.

The CFTC oversees financial markets where traders buy and sell contracts linked to the future prices of assets such as oil, wheat, currencies, and interest rates. These include swaps, which are agreements between parties to exchange payments based on changes in the value of something.

The disagreement centres on whether sports and election betting contracts should also fall under this category.

The two rules facing opposition

The 44 attorneys general are challenging two CFTC rulemakings that seek to change how certain products are classified.

The first is an interim rule that is already in effect. It separates traditional casino-style games, where players bet against a house, from event markets where users place bets against one another. Under this rule, house-backed casino products are treated as gambling rather than financial swaps.

The second rule is still a proposal. It seeks to expand the definition of swaps to include sports and election event contracts. If adopted, the CFTC would use this classification to claim federal oversight of these activities, potentially preventing states from applying their own gambling laws.

The coalition argues that the commission does not have the legal power to make such changes. It also says the CFTC failed to follow required steps when preparing the rules. Davenport accused the regulator of going beyond its responsibilities. “The CFTC continues to stray far outside of its lane by seeking to exclusively regulate certain forms of sports gambling on prediction markets,” she said.

She added that the changes could allow prediction markets to operate without following state gambling rules and protections designed to encourage responsible gaming.

Democratic senators also question CFTC’s approach

The attorneys general are not the only group asking the federal regulator to step back. On November 16, The Crypto Times reported that Nine Democratic senators urged the CFTC to allow states to handle their ongoing legal disputes with prediction market platforms.

According to a WSJ report, the lawmakers sent a letter to the agency on November 16, 2026. The signatories included Adam Schiff of California, Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, and Elissa Slotkin of Michigan.

Their request came after the CFTC issued a directive on November 5, giving prediction market platforms 30 days to either lift domestic geographic restrictions or justify keeping them. The agency based its decision on rules requiring designated contract markets to provide open and equal access to eligible users.

States continue taking prediction markets to court

Meanwhile, several states are pursuing legal action against prediction market companies. For instance, Nevada has secured court orders restricting platforms such as Kalshi from offering certain markets to residents. Louisiana has also sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, and other companies over their prediction market activities.

Utah has taken further action by suing Kalshi and two of its market makers. The state wants a court to block certain sports contracts and has also filed 14 felony counts each against Kalshi CEO Tarek Mansour and COO Luana Lopes Lara over alleged unlawful gambling activities.

Utah-based part of its case on an investigation in which an investigator opened a Kalshi account using a Utah-based internet address and placed 12 sports wagers between September 13 and 26, 2026. The bets involved NFL, MLB, MLS, NHL, and NCAA men’s football games.

New Jersey has also asked the US Supreme Court to hear its case against Kalshi, receiving support from 39 states, the District of Columbia, and 146 tribal nations and organizations.

The dispute could also receive more attention in Congress next year, as Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers. Lawmakers may need to examine whether the Dodd-Frank Act gives the CFTC exclusive authority over prediction markets.

For now, the legal battle continues, with states seeking to protect their gambling laws while the CFTC pushes for greater federal control over the industry.

Also Read: SEC Freezes Assets in Alleged $560M AI Forex Fraud


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *