US Judge Rejects Gemini, CFTC Bid to Overturn $5M Settlement

US Judge Rejects Gemini, CFTC Bid to Overturn $5M Settlement


A US federal judge has rejected a joint request from cryptocurrency exchange Gemini and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to overturn a $5 million settlement reached in January 2025.

According to Bloomberg Law, US District Judge Alvin Hellerstein of the Southern District of New York denied the motion on October 15, leaving the settlement in place. The judge said the arguments presented by Gemini and the CFTC did not provide sufficient grounds to reopen the case.

Gemini’s $5 million penalty underscores how misleading crypto claims can erode investor confidence.

The case highlights regulators’ growing willingness to police crypto, affecting thousands of users relying on platform assurances.

Leaving the settlement intact means continued restrictions on Gemini, limiting future deceptive practices that could harm retail traders.

Gemini and the CFTC filed their joint motion on May 28, 2026, asking the court to vacate the consent order under Rule 60(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. They argued that concerns raised by a later internal review and changes in the agency’s enforcement approach justified reconsidering the settlement. The judge rejected the request, noting that Gemini had agreed to settle just three weeks before the case was scheduled to go to trial.

What Was the Original Case About?

The CFTC sued Gemini in June 2022 over statements the exchange made while the agency was reviewing a proposed Bitcoin futures contract.

The dispute centred on how Gemini described its trading platform and the safeguards it had in place. The consent order said the exchange had described its platform as fully prefunded without disclosing that some customers could trade using loans or advances from people connected to the company.

The regulator also challenged Gemini’s statements about its controls against self-trading. According to the order, the exchange had represented that self-trading was technically prevented and prohibited, even though the safeguards had not always been in place and such trading had occurred. The CFTC also raised concerns about trading volumes, saying they were affected by undisclosed loans, self-trading and other trading arrangements.

Gemini settled the case in January 2025 without admitting or denying the allegations. It agreed to pay $5 million and accept a permanent injunction against making false or misleading statements to the CFTC. Court records cited by Bloomberg confirmed that the penalty has been paid.

Why the Parties Challenged the Settlement

The joint request followed a change in the CFTC’s enforcement approach and an internal review of materials related to the case. In its May 28 filing, the CFTC said its internal review found that the case relied heavily on a whistleblower whose credibility was in question.

The agency also raised concerns that evidence had been withheld from a commissioner during the decision to bring the case and that regulatory authority had been used to pressure Gemini into settling. The parties argued that the complaint would not have been brought under the CFTC’s current enforcement standards.

The arguments reflected a broader shift in the US approach to crypto regulation under President Donald Trump. However, the court had to decide whether the existing settlement could legally be undone, not whether the government’s wider policy towards crypto had changed.

Hellerstein said the additional materials Gemini received after settling might have made the company regret its decision. But regret, he explained, was not enough to show that circumstances had changed in a way that made the agreement unfair.

The judge also pointed to the need for finality in court decisions. A party reconsidering facts that were already present when it agreed to a settlement does not automatically have grounds to reopen the case.

What Happens Now

The ruling leaves the original settlement intact. Gemini’s $5 million payment and the restrictions imposed under the consent order remain in place.

The decision also comes as US regulators have shifted their approach to the crypto sector under President Donald Trump, who has pledged to make the country a global centre for digital assets. However, the judge’s ruling focused on whether the original settlement could legally be overturned, rather than on the administration’s broader crypto policy.

Gemini became a publicly traded company in September 2026 under the name Gemini Space Station Inc. It has also entered prediction markets, where customers can trade on the outcomes of future events.

Neither Gemini nor the CFTC have commented on the ruling. The supplied court records do not indicate whether either party plans to appeal. The Crypto Times will update this report if any statement is shared by Gemini or the CFTC. 

Also Read: CFTC Moves to Build a New Regulatory Framework for Crypto Markets


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *