Papertrade Locks PAPER Inside Protocol, Sparks Backlash From Early Loss Farmers
Papertrade, the synthetic perpetuals protocol built on Hyperliquid’s HyperEVM layer, confirmed on October 19 that its native PAPER token will remain non-transferable for the foreseeable future while also altering the token issuance curve in a manner that dilutes earlier holders.
The announcement, posted by the project’s official account and signed by co-founders Blurr and Jez, followed a launch roughly ten days earlier that had drawn substantial notional volume and deliberate loss-taking activity aimed at minting PAPER.
Papertrade blocks token transfers, citing solvency risks from external leveraged markets, reflecting growing security concerns in DeFi derivatives.
New issuance curve mints ~0.1% of supply per $1 million loss, diluting early farmers and shifting token toward revenue‑share model.
Open interest fell 40% on Bitcoin and 55% on Ether after announcement, underscoring market sensitivity to protocol policy changes.
The protocol enables up to 1,000x leverage on Bitcoin and Ether positions executed as synthetic swaps against a single protocol-owned USDC liquidity pool that starts empty and is funded solely by realized trader losses. Prices are sourced from the midpoint of Hyperliquid’s best bid and offer.
According to the project’s documentation, PAPER is minted exclusively to traders who close losing positions or are liquidated, beginning at a rate of 100 tokens per dollar of eligible loss while the tracked pool remained below roughly $2 million, after which the rate was designed to decay.
The token launched with zero supply, no team or investor allocation, and no airdrop, and could initially only be staked or unstaked. Staked holdings earn USDC distributions drawn from protocol fees and pool surplus under specified conditions.
Team Cites Attack Vectors as Reason to Restrict Transfers
In the official statement, the founders explained that making PAPER transferable would introduce a material risk to the protocol’s solvency. They noted that an external perpetual market on the token would turn it into a leveraged bet on bankroll health.
An attacker who shorts PAPER while simultaneously manipulating the Hyperliquid reference price for BTC or ETH could convert an otherwise unprofitable attack into a profitable one. The post illustrated the point with an example: against a $10 million bankroll, a $15 million price-manipulation attack would lose money on its own, but the addition of $10 million in PAPER short exposure could make the same attack viable.
“If we were to make the token transferable at this point, we are confident we would quickly enter a state too dangerous to allow any material exposure to be taken on papertrade,” the founders wrote, “an end result that benefits no party beyond the wolves who have done the math on the short and are waiting in the wings with sharpened knives.”
They added that perpetual markets on PAPER would act as a self-limiting ceiling on growth and that, at this juncture, they do not have plans to allow off-contract token transferability. The statement also thanked teams that had inquired about pre-market listings and specifically noted constructive engagement with Paragon after an earlier HIP-3 market was opened without prior approval.
Emissions Curve Shift Dilutes Early Holders While Fees Target Bot Activity
Alongside the transferability decision, Papertrade outlined changes to the PAPER issuance model. Going forward, every dollar lost will mint a fixed share of the then-current supply—approximately 0.1 percent of supply per $1 million lost—rather than the prior front-loaded rate that favored the earliest participants. Minting rules near insolvency will also shift to a time-weighted multiplier.
The founders stated that the adjustment would have only a subtle near-term effect but would, over longer horizons, slowly dilute older holders and leave more recent users with a relative advantage, reconstituting the token as closer to ongoing exchange rakeback. They acknowledged the changes would be unpopular with some but described them as necessary based on live operational data.
Separate fee modifications will raise costs on positions closed within 6 basis points of entry during active hours and 10 basis points during off-hours, a structure the team said disproportionately affects low-time-frame bot strategies relative to ordinary traders.
The upgrades, which also include builder codes and certain gas-griefing mitigations, are subject to a timelock after final security review. These developments follow reporting on individual users who converted launch-day losses into substantial staking rewards under the original emissions design, as detailed in coverage of a single wallet’s reward claims.
Community Reaction Centers on Locked Capital and Reduced Exit Options
The combination of continued non-transferability and the emissions revision produced immediate criticism from participants who had treated early losses as a route to concentrated PAPER holdings. Many such users had anticipated eventual secondary-market liquidity; external pre-market contracts were subsequently halted or settled. On-platform activity declined after the post, with Bitcoin open interest falling from roughly $390 million to $230 million and Ether open interest dropping from about $150 million to $66.3 million, according to figures drawn from platform data referenced around the announcement. Total value locked also edged lower from prior peaks near $100 million.
Critics described the outcome as removing both the ability to sell and the relative scarcity advantage early farmers had secured, leaving staking for USDC yields as the primary remaining utility. “Imagine if you farmed late, you just got rekt so hard right now. Idk what the point of $paper even is anymore tbh,” wrote X user cnig69.
Supporters of the decision, including elements of the founders’ framing, argued that external leveraged markets on a solvency-linked token created an unacceptable attack surface that the protocol could not control. The episode occurs against the backdrop of Hyperliquid’s broader growth in perpetual volume, which has repeatedly ranked among the highest across chains.
Papertrade’s choice prioritizes constraints on external short exposure and a more distributed claim on future revenue over the concentrated early-holder upside that had driven much of the initial activity. Whether organic trading volume persists once the farming premium is reduced, and how staking yields alone compare with alternatives on the same underlying chain, will determine whether the protocol retains meaningful participation after the upgrades take effect.
Also read: MEXC to Discontinue Services for Users in Russia and Belarus
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


