Crypto Council Urges SEC to Base Vault Regulation on Control
Key Highlights
- The Crypto Council for Innovation (CCI) submitted a legal framework urging the SEC to clarify how US securities laws apply to crypto vaults.
- CCI argues that vaults governed by fixed code and limited human discretion may fall outside securities laws, while those with greater managerial control may face different treatment.
- The report examines the Securities Act, the Investment Company Act and the Investment Advisers Act.
The Crypto Council for Innovation (CCI) has urged the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to assess crypto vaults based on their technical design, depositor rights, and the discretion retained by those managing them.
In an October 29 post on X, CCI announced that its Vault Coalition had submitted Under Control: A Framework for Applying the Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Vaults, a legal analysis spanning more than 200 pages. The submission responds to the SEC’s request for information on how existing securities laws apply to crypto vaults.
CCI argues that securities treatment should depend on each vault’s design, including the powers permitted by its code and the degree of managerial discretion. Its framework does not propose a blanket exemption for crypto vaults.
The report examines the Securities Act of 1933, the Investment Company Act of 1940, and the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. It also recommends changes to the SEC’s proposed crypto custody rules.
CCI proposes a framework based on control
CCI describes vaults as smart contracts that deploy digital assets through lending, portfolio management or predefined investment strategies. Its Vault Coalition includes representatives from Bitwise, Galaxy and DeFi lending protocol Morpho, with legal advisers from Chapman and Cutler LLP.
The report cites an S&P Global estimate that crypto vaults hold approximately $131 billion in assets. CCI’s X thread does not explain the methodology behind that figure.
CCI’s proposed Control Framework examines the powers available to curators, administrators, and safety guardians, alongside the protections available to depositors. It considers whether these roles can select strategies, change allocations, upgrade contracts, alter rules, or move assets beyond approved destinations.
The framework also considers whether users can verify a vault’s operation, receive advance notice of changes, and withdraw before those changes take effect. CCI argues that these factors should inform the securities-law analysis rather than treating all crypto vaults alike.
Howey and Reves tests apply to vault tokens
Under the Securities Act, CCI examines whether a vault’s receipt token meets the Howey test for an investment contract. The test considers whether an arrangement involves an investment of money in a common enterprise, with an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others.
In a baseline example involving an overcollateralized lending market with immutable rules, CCI argues that the receipt token should not be treated as a security. It says returns in this scenario are determined algorithmically by supply and demand rather than by a person managing the assets.
For vaults involving human oversight, the report proposes examining whether that authority is limited by code, subject to a timelock, and structured to give depositors time to withdraw before changes take effect.
CCI also argues that lending positions may resemble ordinary commercial loans under the Reves test, which courts use to determine whether a note qualifies as a security.
The report acknowledges that courts have not resolved whether code-enforced limits alter the Howey analysis. It says a vault may raise greater securities-law concerns if its curator can add markets, change rates or loan limits, upgrade code, or pause withdrawals without meaningful restrictions.
CCI outlines options under the Investment Company Act
The report examines whether crypto vaults fall within the Investment Company Act of 1940, which regulates certain pooled investment vehicles. For vaults covered by the law, CCI proposes a process modelled on the development of exchange-traded funds, beginning with case-by-case SEC exemptive relief and potentially leading to broader relief or a general rule.
CCI suggests safeguards including on-chain transparency, overcollateralization, permissionless withdrawals, independent code audits and a designated compliance contact. These are proposals, not requirements adopted by the SEC.
When vault curators may be investment advisers
Under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, CCI argues that the law “reaches persons, not code.” It says adviser status should depend on whether a person exercises investment judgment over securities for compensation.
For vaults operated through a legal entity, CCI says the curator should generally be treated as advising that entity rather than individual depositors. It also argues that setting parameters for loans that are not securities, or performing predefined safety actions such as pausing a vault after an incident, should not automatically constitute investment advisory activity.
The report also addresses performance-based fees, which are generally restricted to “qualified clients.” Following an SEC order issued on April 28, 2026, the thresholds rose to $1.4 million in assets under management with the adviser or a net worth of at least $2.7 million, excluding equity in a primary residence. The new thresholds took effect on June 29, 2026.
Because anonymous depositors may be difficult to verify against these requirements, CCI asks the SEC to consider relief under Section 205(e), subject to safeguards such as audited code and withdrawal rights.
On anti-money laundering rules, FinCEN postponed the effective date of its investment-adviser AML rule from January 1, 2026, to January 1, 2028. CCI argues that the obligations should focus on firms that hold customer assets or control customer relationships, such as exchanges offering vault products.
CCI acknowledges limits of its proposal
CCI says vaults outside the scope of securities laws would still be subject to other legal requirements, including laws against fraud. It also argues that retail users may need plain-language disclosures even when a vault’s operation can be verified through code.
The report notes that public access to a vault could be relevant under the Reves analysis. Its proposed interpretation has not been tested in court, and the legal treatment of an individual vault would depend on its design and operation.
SEC’s broader crypto regulatory approach
CCI’s submission comes amid other SEC initiatives involving crypto regulation and digital asset market infrastructure.
On October 21, Ripple had urged the SEC to finalize its proposed framework for regulating crypto assets as the public comment period closed. The proposal includes potential fundraising exemptions of up to $75 million and a conditional safe harbor for certain crypto assets.
On October 23, The Crypto Times reported that the SEC had included tokenization and Treasury clearing reforms in its fiscal 2027 examination priorities. The agency said its Division of Examinations would assess risks associated with evolving financial market infrastructure.
Although these initiatives address different areas of regulation, CCI’s submission focuses on how existing securities laws apply to crypto vaults and the people who manage them.
What CCI wants from the SEC
CCI is seeking interpretive guidance on how securities laws apply to different vault designs, a roadmap for Section 6© exemptive applications under the Investment Company Act and revisions to the proposed custody rules.
The group said it was prepared to engage with the SEC’s Crypto Task Force, led by Commissioner Hester Peirce. It also points to an earlier Senate version of the CLARITY Act that included vault-related provisions but did not advance past a procedural vote in September.
The SEC has not endorsed CCI’s recommendations. Any change in regulatory treatment would depend on future agency action, applicable law and the facts of individual vaults.
Also Read: FCA Secures Court Deal to Stop HTX Crypto Promotions in UK
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


