Justin Drake Says Bitcoin Could Freeze Satoshi’s Coins to Counter Quantum Threat
Bitcoin may implement protocol-level freeze for lost coins, using BIP‑361 and BIP‑360 to render vulnerable addresses unspendable.
Ethereum plans post‑quantum migration by 2028‑2029, allowing seed‑phrase holders to move funds via zero‑knowledge “proof of seed”.
Approximately 10‑15% of Bitcoin supply is lost versus under 1% of Ether, influencing each network’s freeze versus free‑market response.
Ethereum Foundation researcher Justin Drake predicted that Bitcoin will choose to freeze lost coins, including those attributed to its creator Satoshi Nakamoto, before a quantum computer can steal them, while Ethereum will leave its own lost coins exposed.
The difference comes down to how much of each network’s supply is at stake, Drake said. He estimated that 10% to 15% of all bitcoin is lost, compared with less than 1% of ether that would be exposed to a quantum attacker.
Drake made the remarks during an audience question-and-answer session at Devcon 8, the Ethereum Foundation’s developer conference in Mumbai, on November 4. The session followed his opening-day talk on post-quantum and “post-AI” cryptography with a fellow researcher.
Two Options for Coins Whose Owners Are Gone
Drake split old wallets into two groups. The first are wallets whose owners still have their seed phrases and can move funds to quantum-safe addresses. For those, he said, the task is education and the tools for a calm, steady migration.
The second group is wallets where the funds are simply lost. Drake said a network has two broad choices for them.
The first is to do nothing and let an eventual quantum or AI attacker take the funds. Drake described this as a kind of bug bounty for whoever builds a powerful enough quantum computer. The second is to freeze those coins at the protocol level so that no one, including an attacker, can move them.
Why Bitcoin and Ethereum Face Different Choices
Drake said he hopes Ethereum will not have to make that decision at all, because the share of ether that is both lost and exposed to quantum attack is very small. He put it at under 1%, low enough that he said the network can tolerate it being stolen.
Bitcoin is in a different position, he said. Drake cited the roughly 1 million BTC attributed to Satoshi Nakamoto, about 5% of the supply, and estimated that another 5% belonged to very early users who kept no backups of their keys. He put the total share of lost bitcoin at about 10% to 15%.
He said a single attacker taking 10% of the bitcoin supply would be very damaging. His prediction is that Bitcoin will take the interventionist route and freeze the coins, while Ethereum will take what he called the free-market, “pure cypherpunk” approach.
Drake added that this would make the two networks one for one: Ethereum intervened after the 2016 DAO hack, and Bitcoin would intervene over quantum.
The Shipwreck Comparison
Drake said some quantum computing companies already include lost crypto in their pitches to investors. The idea, as he described it, is to recover funds from old wallets, take a cut, and return the rest, for example, to the U.S. government.
He compared it to how sunken treasure is handled. When a ship carrying gold sinks, he said, a government can hire a company to recover it. The company keeps a share, which he put at around 10% as an example, and the rest goes into a government-controlled fund. Rightful owners can claim from that fund, and anything unclaimed stays with the government.
Drake did not name the quantum companies he was referring to.
What Drake Says Ethereum Users Should Do
For people who still control their wallets, Drake said seed phrases will work exactly as they do today. Users can keep their existing 12- or 24-word phrase but will need to move funds to new, post-quantum addresses derived from it. He said wallet apps could detect older addresses and offer a one-step migration.
He said there is no emergency and no need to rush. He warned that scammers will try to frighten users into downloading fake “post-quantum secure” wallets and advised people to take their time.
The seed phrase stays safe because the process that turns it into a private key relies on hash functions, which Drake said are quantum secure. Today’s signatures, which rely on elliptic-curve cryptography, are the part a quantum computer could break.
Vitalik Buterin’s Emergency Plan
Asked what Ethereum could do in a sudden quantum emergency, Drake pointed to a March 2024 post by Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin on the Ethereum Research forum, titled “How to hard-fork to save most users’ funds in a quantum emergency.”
Under that plan, Ethereum would declare today’s ECDSA signatures invalid. Users would instead move funds by submitting a zero-knowledge proof that they know the seed phrase behind an address, without revealing it. Drake called this “proof of seed” and said it would be used only in the most extreme emergency.
Drake said the mechanism would work for almost all users but not for some large custodians, which secure funds with multi-party computation rather than seed phrases. He advised such custodians to avoid revealing their public keys at all, moving funds to a fresh address each time they spend.
Bitcoin’s Freeze Debate Is Already Under Way
Bitcoin developers are already arguing over a freeze. In April, Casa co-founder Jameson Lopp and five co-authors published BIP-361, “Post Quantum Migration and Legacy Signature Sunset.” It sets out a phased plan that would eventually make coins in quantum-vulnerable addresses unspendable unless they are moved, The Crypto Times reported.
The proposal depends on BIP-360, a separate framework for quantum-resistant addresses, and has no activation timeline. Lopp has said publicly that he does not like his own proposal but considers quantum theft the worse outcome. Critics have described a freeze as confiscation.
Drake’s view is that Bitcoin will ultimately choose that route. Ethereum’s own post-quantum roadmap sets December 2029 as the target for quantum resistance across its main protocol layers, and Drake said on Tuesday he hopes the full transition can finish by December 2028, as The Crypto Times reported from Devcon 8.
Also Read: Ethereum Advances Quantum Security Deadline to 2028 at Devcon
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


