Bitcoin Developer Proposes Quantum Landmines to Trap Future BTC Thieves
Bitcoin could face a new way to protect vulnerable holdings from future quantum-computer attacks. A proposal suggests using hidden ownership proofs, financial collateral and auction mechanisms to make attempts to steal older BTC costly for attackers.
Cory Fields, who works on Bitcoin’s software at MIT’s Digital Currency Initiative, shared the ideas on November 5 through the Bitcoin Development mailing list. He described them as thought experiments rather than finalized technical proposals, noting that the rules required to implement them through a soft fork still need further work.
If adopted, Quantum Landmines could force attackers to lose collateral, deterring future quantum thefts.
Staked Auctions may let owners pre‑commit funds, creating a market that raises the cost of stealing dormant Bitcoin.
Sats Auction proposes post‑attack bidding, potentially making quantum attackers bid more than target value to avoid losing.
The proposals come as Bitcoin developers debate how to protect older holdings without permanently locking out legitimate owners who have not moved their funds to quantum-resistant addresses.
How Quantum Landmines Could Protect Bitcoin
Fields’ first idea, called Quantum Landmines, uses hidden ownership proofs to create a financial trap for potential attackers.
In his example, Alice holds 1 BTC in an older, quantum-vulnerable output and another 1 BTC in a quantum-safe output. She also creates a small quantum-safe output containing a hidden proof that she knew the private key associated with her older Bitcoin before quantum attacks became possible.
If someone later attempts to steal her vulnerable BTC, the proposed rules would require the transaction to include another 1 BTC as collateral from a quantum-safe wallet. Both amounts would be locked in a 2 BTC output for a waiting period of 30 days.
During that period, Alice could reveal her previously committed proof and move the funds using a designated quantum-safe public key. If the proof is valid, she could also claim the attacker’s collateral.
This means an attacker could lose their own Bitcoin while failing to take control of the targeted coins. The hidden proof would also make it difficult to identify which vulnerable holdings were protected by landmines before attempting a theft.
Staked Auctions Could Protect Lost Coins
Fields acknowledged that landmines would not protect every vulnerable Bitcoin holding. Some older wallets are believed to have lost their private keys, leaving no original owner available to reveal proof of ownership.
To address this problem, he proposed a second approach called Staked Auction.
Under this model, Bitcoin holders could commit funds to quantum-safe outputs before quantum attacks become possible. These outputs would contain hidden bids linked to specific vulnerable holdings.
Field demonstrated his concept with a dormant wallet that has 50 BTC. If any malicious entity wanted to spend those coins, they would have to put up 50 BTC as collateral. The attacker then devised an output for 95 BTC (a 45 BTC bid). When the initial period ends, then an auction would be in effect.
An attacker who had committed funds previously with a covert bid of 40 BTC could open that bid and claim 40 BTC from the attacker collateral. Others could submit competing bids in the auction.
Fields also suggested different ways to handle losing bids, including returning funds to unsuccessful bidders, penalizing them or directing unused collateral to miners.
Sats Auction Could Raise Attack Costs
A third concept, called Sats Auction, removes the requirement for participants to stake Bitcoin before quantum attacks become possible.
Instead, every attempt to spend vulnerable legacy coins would trigger an auction after the initial waiting period.
The highest bidder would receive the vulnerable coins after paying their bid, while the second-highest bidder would lose their committed amount without receiving anything.
The mechanism draws on the Dollar Auction game, where participants may continue bidding to avoid becoming the losing second-highest bidder.
Fields suggested this could push bidders to keep raising their offers, potentially forcing a quantum attacker to commit more Bitcoin than the value of the targeted coins. The original owner could also participate without making an advance commitment.
Bitcoin’s Quantum Migration Debate
The proposals add to Bitcoin’s ongoing discussion about protecting coins from sufficiently powerful quantum computers.
Bitcoin also use elliptic-curve cryptography to sign transactions. With a powerful enough quantum computer using Shor’s algorithm, one could take the public key that appears in the transaction data and back-derive the private key, spending any affected coins.
Older Pay-to-Public-Key (P2PK) outputs are among the main concerns because the public keys are now revealed on chain. The discussion also includes unspent outputs, including funds linked to Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto.
In April, developers published BIP-361’s post-quantum migration proposal, which outlined a phased approach to moving funds into quantum-resistant addresses and eventually restricting vulnerable legacy signatures.
More recently, Coinbase outlined Bitcoin’s security priorities for the post-quantum era, highlighting migration challenges and concerns surrounding dormant holdings.
Fields’ ideas offer a different approach by using economic incentives rather than relying entirely on freezing vulnerable coins.
Implementation Questions Remain Open
Fields has not presented the three mechanisms as finalized Bitcoin upgrades. Their implementation would require new quantum-safe output types and additional spending rules before and after a potential quantum threat.
He also questioned whether the main goal should be preventing attacks, encouraging advance staking or redistributing vulnerable coins through auctions.
For now, the proposals remain conceptual. Further discussion among Bitcoin developers will determine whether these ideas can become workable protocol rules and gain wider community support.
Also Read: Core Scientific’s Bitcoin Mining Era Nears Its End as Colocation Revenue Takes Over
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


