Hyperliquid Policy Center Backs CFTC Plan to Classify Event Contracts as Swaps

Hyperliquid Policy Center Backs CFTC Plan to Classify Event Contracts as Swaps


Key Highlights

The Hyperliquid Policy Center (HPC) has backed the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) proposal to classify event contracts as swaps, while asking the agency to distinguish them from wagers offered by licensed casinos and sportsbooks.

In two comment letters submitted on November 16, the policy organization supported a proposed rule covering event contracts tied to sports, politics, culture, and weather. It also backed a separate interim final rule excluding certain casino-style gambling products offered by licensed operators from the swap definition.

HPC recommended one change to the proposed event-contract rule: adding a cross-reference to the gambling exclusion in the companion rule. It said the amendment would clarify how the two provisions apply to products that may be based on the same event.

The submissions come amid legal disputes over whether prediction-market contracts fall under federal derivatives regulation or state gambling laws.

HPC distinguishes event contracts from sportsbook wagers

HPC argued that traditional sportsbook wagers and event contracts traded on designated contract markets (DCMs) are different products, even when they depend on the same underlying event.

A sportsbook generally acts as the counterparty to each wager and sets the odds. Traditional wagers are also generally non-transferable and do not trade on a secondary market. Where a sportsbook offers a cash-out option, it typically repurchases the position at a price it determines.

Event contracts traded on DCMs operate differently. They are standardized and priced through competing bids and offers on an exchange order book. The exchange provides the marketplace rather than taking the opposite side of each customer’s position. These contracts can be sold or closed before an event takes place and are cleared through a registered clearinghouse.

According to HPC, the structure of a product, the role of its provider and the market where it trades should determine its regulatory treatment, rather than the event on which its payout depends. HPC cited other financial products that can provide similar economic exposure but fall under different regulatory regimes. Its examples included bond insurance and credit default swaps, crop insurance and agricultural options, and forwards and futures.

The organization also pointed to the CFTC and Securities and Exchange Commission’s 2012 rulemaking, which excluded certain insurance products and ordinary consumer and commercial agreements from the swap definition based on the provider and structure of the products.

Proposed swap definition

In its comment on the proposed rule, titled Further Definition of “Swap”—Inclusions, HPC supported the CFTC’s plan to add event contracts to the swap definition under Regulation 1.3. The proposal would cover event contracts based on sports, politics, cultural, and weather-related events.

HPC argued that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) already provides a statutory basis for treating these contracts as swaps. It pointed to provisions covering payments dependent on the occurrence or non-occurrence of an event associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence.

The organization traced this language to amendments made by Congress in 2000 and 2010. It said the 2000 definition of an “excluded commodity” included event-based contingencies, while the Dodd-Frank Act later incorporated similar language into the statutory definition of a swap.

HPC also cited the CEA’s Special Rule, which gives the CFTC authority to review certain event-based contracts involving activities such as gaming. According to HPC, the proposal would clarify how the existing statutory definition applies to event contracts rather than expand the commission’s jurisdiction.

The letter also referred to the CFTC’s earlier treatment of event-based products, including contracts on election outcomes and binary event contracts listed on regulated markets. HPC cited these examples as evidence that event contracts have previously been traded within the federal derivatives framework.

Cross-reference to gambling exclusion

Although HPC supported the event-contract proposal, it said the rule text should explicitly refer to the separate exclusion for licensed gambling products.

The proposed rule would include event contracts based on sports and other events, while the interim final rule excludes certain wagers offered by licensed gaming operators. HPC said the overlap in the types of events covered could create uncertainty without a direct reference to the exclusion.

HPC recommended revising the proposed provision to exclude agreements, contracts or transactions already covered under paragraph (7) of the swap definition, which contains the casino-style gambling exclusion. The organization said the change would preserve the exclusion for qualifying licensed wagers without removing DCM-traded event contracts from the proposed swap definition.

HPC also asked the CFTC to define an event contract using language already present in the CEA. It recommended describing such a contract as one whose payment depends on the occurrence, extent of an occurrence or contingency, rather than a change in the price, rate, value or level of a commodity.

HPC said this clarification would distinguish event-based contracts from price-based derivatives while grounding the definition in the existing statute.

Conflicting state-level interpretations

In its separate comment on the casino-gambling exclusion, HPC urged the CFTC to finalize the interim rule without changing its text. The organization pointed to differences in state gambling laws and court interpretations, arguing that these could lead to inconsistent treatment of prediction-market contracts across jurisdictions.

HPC cited a Washington state court ruling that restricted certain categories of event contracts while allowing others. It also referred to differing interpretations from the Sixth, Ninth, and Third Circuit Courts of Appeals.

HPC warned that broad interpretations of state gambling laws could affect derivatives linked to commodities, energy, interest rates and currencies, not just sports-related contracts. It argued that leaving their classification to individual states could result in different regulatory treatment for similar products.

The organization maintained that Congress gave the CFTC authority to define the boundaries of the swap category under the CEA. HPC also supported the commission’s decision to issue the interim final rule without first conducting a standard notice-and-comment process. It said the agency was addressing uncertainty created by ongoing litigation rather than changing the existing regulatory framework.

HPC seeks clarification on licensing and new products

Beyond supporting the casino-gambling exclusion, HPC proposed several clarifications for the CFTC to include in the final rule’s preamble.

First, it asked the agency to clarify that whether a product is regulated as gambling should be determined under the laws of the state or Tribal jurisdiction that licensed the operator. HPC said a license issued in one jurisdiction should not automatically determine the product’s status elsewhere.

Second, it recommended clarifying that a state cannot classify a contract traded on a CFTC-registered exchange as an excluded gambling product simply by describing it as a wager under state law.

Third, HPC asked the CFTC to clarify that the exclusion does not extend to over-the-counter swaps between eligible contract participants. It said the rule should not provide a basis for states to claim authority over bilateral swaps merely because they reference an event.

The organization also addressed how the CFTC should assess new products that may not fit neatly into the distinction between traditional wagers and exchange-traded derivatives.

It suggested that the agency include a nonexclusive list of factors, such as whether an operator acts as the counterparty to every transaction, sets prices unilaterally, provides a secondary market, allows positions to be transferred or closed before an event, and earns revenue through a spread or transaction fees.

HPC said prior regulation of a product as gambling under state or Tribal law could also be considered when assessing its classification. The organization further argued that the interim final rule does not create new compliance obligations but clarifies how licensed gambling products are treated under the existing swap definition.

Crypto industry has called for federal prediction-market rules

HPC’s latest submissions follow earlier efforts by crypto industry participants to establish federal rules for prediction markets.

In July, Hyperliquid and Multicoin Capital backed the CFTC’s approach to prediction-market regulation, arguing that federal oversight could reduce uncertainty for platforms operating across state lines. They supported treating qualifying event contracts as federally regulated derivatives rather than subjecting them to differing state gambling rules.

The National Football League (NFL), however, took a different position in a July filing, urging the CFTC to impose tighter restrictions on sports-related event contracts. The contrasting submissions highlighted disagreements over how these markets should be regulated.

The dispute has also reached the courts. In May, the CFTC backed Kalshi in its legal fight against Ohio, arguing that prediction contracts fall under federal derivatives regulation. Ohio had sought to classify Kalshi’s sports event markets as unlicensed gambling.

HPC has separately engaged with the CFTC on other derivatives issues. In August, its policy center urged the agency to continue a phased review of perpetual futures, including research into their potential use beyond cryptocurrency markets. In September, the organization brought in former US Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar to challenge CME’s lawsuit against the CFTC, arguing that CME lacked standing.

CFTC to review HPC’s requested changes

The CFTC published the interim final rule excluding casino-style gambling products from the swap definition and the companion proposal covering event contracts in the Federal Register on October 19, 2026.

HPC’s two submissions address the treatment of licensed gambling products and qualifying event contracts traded on regulated derivatives exchanges. The organization wants the CFTC to retain the gambling exclusion while adopting the proposed event-contract provision with its requested cross-reference.

The commission has yet to decide whether to adopt the proposed event-contract provision or incorporate the additional clarifications requested by HPC.

Also Read: Coinbase, Broadridge Launch Open Standard for Tokenized Equity Holders


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *