Hyperliquid Policy Center Urges FCA to Focus DeFi Rules on Control

Hyperliquid Policy Center Urges FCA to Focus DeFi Rules on Control


Key Highlights

The Hyperliquid Policy Center (HPC) has urged the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to base its proposed cryptoasset and decentralized finance (DeFi) rules on the functions performed by individual participants and the degree of control they exercise over financial activities.

According to an announcement published on November 18, the Hyperliquid Policy Center submitted responses to the FCA’s Consultation Paper CP26/36 on cryptoasset perimeter guidance and Guidance Consultation GC26/7 on DeFi, addressing the regulatory treatment of blockchain infrastructure, market participants, and firms offering crypto-related services.

HPC argued that regulatory obligations should apply to identifiable persons who exercise unilateral control over regulated functions or directly provide regulated products and services to clients. It said this approach would allow regulated firms to use public blockchain infrastructure while remaining accountable for their own activities.

The UK’s cryptoasset regulatory regime is scheduled to take effect on October 25, 2027, according to the submission.

HPC wants FCA to base DeFi rules on individual control

HPC said the FCA’s technology-neutral approach was appropriate but argued that the regulator should distinguish between participants based on their actual responsibilities and authority.

It asked the FCA to assess each participant in an onchain market separately rather than treating the entire arrangement as a single regulated entity. This assessment should consider whether a person can independently change how a system operates after deployment.

According to the submission, indicators of unilateral control could include the ability to halt or reverse transactions, settle them at a chosen price, or change a system’s economic terms without collective approval.

HPC added that regulatory assessments should account for changes in a protocol’s governance and operating structure as it becomes more decentralized. A participant’s role during a system’s initial development may differ from its responsibilities once the network operates through distributed governance.

Validators and developers should not automatically be regulated

The policy group argued that validators and software developers should not fall within the regulatory perimeter simply because they help maintain public blockchain networks or receive compensation for their work.

It said validators generally process transactions according to predetermined network rules rather than exercising independent discretion over users’ financial activities. Similarly, developing or upgrading software does not, by itself, amount to providing a regulated service.

HPC cited Hyperliquid’s proof-of-stake network as an example. Its submission said validators are selected based on stake, blocks require approval representing more than two-thirds of the total stake, and changes to network rules depend on validators collectively adopting updated node software.

The group said routine maintenance, software upgrades, and validator rewards should not automatically disqualify a network from being considered decentralized. It also argued that a foundation or governance organization should not be treated as equivalent to the underlying protocol without evidence that it exercises relevant control.

Clarity on proprietary trading and order books

HPC supported excluding proprietary trading conducted on a firm’s own account when the firm is not providing a service to another person.

However, it raised concerns about the FCA’s proposed approach to identifying whether a firm expects to transact with retail customers. The group argued that the regulator should distinguish bilateral trading from activity conducted through multilateral central limit order books.

In bilateral transactions, a trader may directly select or deal with a particular counterparty. In a multilateral order book, however, orders are matched according to predefined rules, such as price-time priority, without proprietary traders necessarily knowing or choosing the other side of a transaction.

HPC warned that treating every trade with a retail participant as evidence of a regulated service could discourage proprietary traders and market makers from participating in order-book venues. It said this could reduce liquidity, widen spreads, and affect execution for retail customers.

The group therefore asked the FCA to apply its retail-counterparty expectations to bilateral dealings rather than automatically extending them to multilateral order books, including decentralized trading venues.

Technical service providers should remain outside the perimeter

HPC also supported the proposed exclusion for technical service providers under Article 9Z2A of the Regulated Activities Order. It argued that providers offering technical access to blockchain networks should not be treated as financial intermediaries when they do not hold customer assets, exercise transaction discretion, recommend products, determine prices, or route transactions based on their own judgment.

The submission also addressed how providers charge for their services. HPC said fixed fees, including fixed amounts or percentages charged per transaction, should not alone indicate that a provider is acting as an intermediary.

By contrast, fees that vary according to the venue, protocol, route, or counterparty could create incentives for a provider to steer users towards particular transactions or services.

The group further argued that an interface should not automatically fall within the regulatory perimeter simply because it connects users to one protocol or provider. The relevant question, it said, should be whether users retain the choice to use the service.

HPC addresses operational risks of public blockchains

On operational resilience, HPC said the FCA should rely on existing requirements under the Senior Management Arrangements, Systems and Controls (SYSC) framework rather than introduce a separate regime for blockchain infrastructure.

It argued that regulated firms should remain responsible for assessing risks associated with the protocols and third-party applications they use. However, the regulator should distinguish between risks arising from the underlying blockchain, an application built on it, and a firm’s own connection to the network.

HPC also pointed to features of distributed networks that it said could improve operational resilience. A network may continue processing transactions when an individual validator becomes unavailable, while public transaction records allow activity to be independently inspected.

The submission contrasted this with a November 2025 cooling failure at a third-party data center used by a major derivatives exchange, which forced the exchange to halt trading. HPC cited the incident as an example of how reliance on centralized infrastructure can create operational risks.

It also said decentralized governance mechanisms may help networks respond to incidents by allowing participants to coordinate changes or pause activity. However, the group cautioned that unilateral intervention powers could create their own risks.

Group calls for risk-based financial crime controls

HPC said the transparency of public blockchains can help regulated firms trace transactions and identify exposure to illicit activity.

It referred to the US GENIUS Act, which requires permitted payment stablecoin issuers to have the technological capability to comply with lawful orders to freeze, seize, or burn stablecoins, or prevent their transfer.

The group argued that financial crime controls should reflect the nature and extent of a firm’s exposure rather than require the elimination of all risks associated with public blockchain activity.

It also asked the FCA to distinguish direct exposure to sanctioned or illicit addresses from indirect exposure involving intervening legitimate transactions. Firms should be able to apply documented screening processes and proportionate thresholds for enhanced due diligence and reporting, according to the submission.

The policy group opposed requiring developers to build specific compliance tools directly into blockchain protocols.

It argued that such requirements could become outdated as networks evolve and may not be suitable for different technical designs. HPC also warned that mandating particular tools could create the appearance of compliance without necessarily delivering effective outcomes.

Instead, it favoured an outcome-based approach under which regulated firms remain responsible for meeting their legal obligations, regardless of whether they use public blockchain infrastructure.

The submission described onchain finance as the use of public blockchain networks by regulated firms to provide financial products and services. In HPC’s view, regulation should focus on the identifiable firms and individuals offering those services rather than treating the underlying infrastructure as a regulated intermediary.

FCA’s earlier guidance and authorization plans for crypto firms

The FCA’s latest consultations build on its earlier work to define how existing financial rules will apply to cryptoasset activities and DeFi. In October, the FCA examined how the regulator’s proposed guidance could affect firms using decentralized finance and which activities may fall outside the forthcoming authorization requirements.

Earlier, in September, the UK’s authorization process had also been a focus ahead of the new regime. The firms seeking to continue operating under transitional arrangements would need to apply during the window running from September 30, 2026, to February 28, 2027.

HPC’s latest submission also follows earlier industry responses to the FCA’s approach. In June, Aave argued that non-discretionary infrastructure should be distinguished from traditional intermediary activities when determining regulatory obligations.

Hyperliquid Policy Center’s earlier crypto regulatory submissions

The latest FCA submission follows the policy center’s earlier efforts to influence crypto regulation in other jurisdictions. On November 16, HPC backed a US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) proposal to classify qualifying event contracts as swaps, while seeking clarity on how the proposal would interact with the exclusion for licensed gambling products.

In October, the group also urged the European Union to apply the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II) framework to crypto perpetual contracts, arguing that these products should be assessed under existing derivatives rules as the European Commission reviewed how MiCA applies to newer crypto products.

In its latest submission, HPC offered to provide the FCA with technical briefings and help develop practical examples as the regulator finalizes its cryptoasset perimeter and DeFi guidance.

Also Read: GTA 6 Launch Sees Kalshi Offer $135K to Play the Game Full-Time


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *