Kalshi Asks NY Judge for Notice Before Any Emergency Order

Kalshi Asks NY Judge for Notice Before Any Emergency Order


New York sued Kalshi after five years of inaction, alleging illegal gambling despite the platform holding a CFTC license.

Judge Broderick sent the case to state court, ruling federal jurisdiction insufficient and emphasizing state authority over gambling regulation.

Kalshi claims the state’s emergency order would shut down its federally regulated exchange, citing CFTC emergency order preventing market disruption.

Kalshi has asked a New York state judge not to grant the state an emergency order against it without first hearing from the company. The prediction market argues that the order New York sought earlier would shut down its exchange nationwide and conflict with a directive from its federal regulator, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

The request came hours after a federal judge sent New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi back to state court. That move revived the state’s ability to ask again for a temporary restraining order (TRO), which had been put on hold while the case was in federal court.

Kalshi’s lawyers at Milbank filed the letter with Justice Melissa A. Crane of the Supreme Court of New York, New York County, at 11:21 PM Eastern Time on November 19, 2026 (04:21 UTC on November 20), in People ex rel. James v. KalshiEX LLC (Index No. 453272/2026), according to the court’s electronic filing system.

Federal Judge Sends the Case Back

Earlier on November 19, US District Judge Vernon Broderick of the Southern District of New York granted New York’s motion to remand the case to state court, according to the court’s opinion and order (26-CV-6550).

New York Attorney General Letitia James filed the suit in state court on July 31, 2026. It seeks to permanently stop Kalshi “from continuing to operate a gambling business in New York without being licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission.”

The state brought eight claims under the New York State Constitution, New York penal and racing laws, and the federal Wire Act. According to the court’s summary of the petition, Kalshi lets users aged 18 to 20 trade on its platform, although New York requires mobile sports bettors to be at least 21. Kalshi also offers contracts on New York college sports, which the state bars betting on.

“No matter what they call themselves, prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple,” James said when the suit was filed, according to her office. Kalshi moved the case to federal court the same day.

Kalshi argued it could move the case under the federal officer removal statute because it holds a CFTC license as a designated contract market (DCM). Broderick said Kalshi’s license was a defense, and a federal defense does not give a federal court jurisdiction.

“The federal commodities regulations cited by the CFTC may permit DCMs to offer event contracts, but they do not guarantee a right to offer such contracts or require DCMs to offer them, nor do they prohibit states from banning them altogether,” he wrote, quoting a ruling in a separate case.

Broderick said the Wire Act claim raises a federal question but called Kalshi’s argument linking it to CFTC jurisdiction “attenuated.” He found the issue was not substantial enough to keep the case in federal court. He said a federal forum would disrupt “the federal-state balance approved by Congress,” because “the scope of laws regulating gambling and lotteries is clearly a matter of predominantly state concern.”

He also noted that the CFTC had not sought to join the New York case, even though it had intervened in a Rhode Island case involving Kalshi. Broderick denied New York’s request for attorneys’ fees, finding that Kalshi had “colorable arguments” for removal. He said he could not rule on Kalshi’s request to limit the state’s investigative subpoena because the court no longer had jurisdiction over the case.

Kalshi Asks to Be Heard First

On July 31, 2026, the Attorney General’s office asked the state court for an ex parte TRO, meaning an order issued without the other side present. According to Kalshi’s letter, the state court denied that request on August 3, 2026, as moot “without prejudice to a new motion should the federal court remand this special proceeding.”

With the case back in state court, the Attorney General can renew that request. “Kalshi respectfully submits that any renewed motion for temporary or preliminary relief warrants briefing and that there is no justification for issuance of ex parte relief under the circumstances present here,” Sean M. Murphy, a Milbank partner, wrote in the letter. Kalshi asked for a status conference “at the Court’s earliest convenience.”

Kalshi Points to the State’s Timing

Kalshi argued that there is no emergency justifying an order issued without notice. According to the letter, Kalshi’s exchange launched in July 2021 and has been headquartered in New York since then, yet the Attorney General did not sue until July 2026. “That five years of inaction is diametrically opposed to any claim of imminent, irreparable harm,” the letter said.

Kalshi said it has offered sports event contracts since January 2025. It said the state “voluntarily refrained from enforcement for nine months” while it waited for a ruling on Kalshi’s preliminary injunction motion in a parallel federal case. That decision is now on appeal at the Second Circuit.

Daniel Wallach, a gaming law attorney, wrote on X that the letter leaves out some of the history. He said New York sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter in October 2025 and agreed to hold off on enforcement until the preliminary injunction ruling, and that Kalshi then sought an injunction pending appeal.

‘Within or From New York’

According to the letter, the state’s proposed order would bar Kalshi from offering “contracts relating to sports, culture, elections, and other events” “within or from New York or to persons in New York.” Kalshi said “other events” is undefined, so the order “would reach every contract Kalshi lists.”

Because Kalshi is headquartered in New York, it argued the order “would shut down a federally regulated exchange for every customer, everywhere.”

The letter said that would include states covered by the Third Circuit, “which recently blessed Kalshi’s operation in that region, finding that state gaming laws are preempted by federal law.”

Citing the Attorney General’s own figures of $178 billion in annualized trading volume and a $22 billion valuation, Kalshi said the order “would likely force the liquidation of all open positions, disrupting markets far beyond this State.”

The CFTC Emergency Order

According to the letter, on August 11, 2026, the CFTC used its emergency authority under Section 8a(9) of the Commodity Exchange Act. It found that the Attorney General’s action and TRO motion were themselves a “major market disturbance” and that a sudden shutdown would pose an “existential threat” to federally regulated markets. The CFTC ordered Kalshi to “continue to perform its functions as an exchange,” the letter said.

“The OSC would order the opposite,” Milbank wrote, referring to the state’s order to show cause. “Relief that would contradict a federal emergency order should not issue without full briefing, and certainly not ex parte.”

What Happens Next

According to a footnote in the letter, Kalshi’s lawyers had contacted the state on the evening of November 19 to propose a discussion on “an orderly process for proceedings in state court following remand.” The state “responded that it would get back to Kalshi tomorrow regarding the meet and confer request,” the letter said.

As of publication, the court had not scheduled a hearing, and the Attorney General’s office had not filed a renewed TRO application. Separately, Kalshi’s lawsuit against the New York State Gaming Commission is pending at the Second Circuit, after Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction on July 7, 2026.

Also Read: Coinbase Pushes CFTC to Fast-Track Event Contract Rules Amid State Legal Battles


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.







Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *