Better Markets Questions SEC Oversight of Tokenized Trading Venues
Key Highlights
- Better Markets challenged the SEC’s temporary conditional exemption for tokenized securities venues under File No. 4-927.
- The group argues the five-year exemption should have undergone notice-and-comment rulemaking under the Administrative Procedure Act rather than being introduced through an exemptive order.
- Better Markets questions the framework’s oversight requirements, arguing that venues may begin operations without affirmative SEC or FINRA approval or baseline registration requirements.
Better Markets, a nonprofit advocacy organization, submitted a comment letter to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on October 22, 2026, raising legal and policy objections to the agency’s temporary conditional exemption for tokenized securities venues.
In its letter, filed under File No. 4-927 and Release No. 34-106402, the group argued that the exemption represents a significant change to secondary-market trading rules for National Market System (NMS) stocks.
Better Markets said the SEC should have adopted the framework through notice-and-comment rulemaking under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), rather than granting relief through an exemptive order under Section 36(a)(1) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The group also questioned the decision to make the changes effective before the Commission received public feedback on the framework.
Background of the SEC order
On September 17, 2026, the SEC issued an order granting qualifying blockchain-based trading venues a five-year conditional exemption from certain exchange and dealer requirements under the Exchange Act.
The relief covers distributed-ledger trading venues dealing in eligible tokenized NMS stocks. It exempts qualifying venues from the definition of an exchange under Section 3(a)(1) and provides separate relief from the definition of a dealer under Section 3(a)(5) for certain liquidity providers.
Participating venues may use permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools. The order distinguishes tokens that represent actual underlying shares from synthetic products that only track prices; the latter are excluded.
Certain liquidity providers using their own capital in eligible pools also receive limited relief, subject to conditions covering listed securities, platform access, trading activity, and blockchain infrastructure. The exemption is temporary and conditional rather than a permanent framework.
Better Markets questions the SEC’s legal authority
Better Markets argues that the scale of the changes, which it describes as the largest rewrite of secondary-market equity trading rules since Regulation NMS, requires formal rulemaking and a full economic analysis under Section 3(f) of the Exchange Act.
The letter states that the Commission may not redefine entire categories of market participants through an adjudicatory order that functions as a legislative rule of general future effect. It cites judicial precedent holding that agencies cannot avoid Administrative Procedure Act requirements by labeling rules as orders.
The group also said the SEC has historically used notice-and-comment procedures even for narrower exemptions and has not justified the departure from that practice.
The letter further asserts that the order imposes new information-collection burdens on public companies, which must monitor and respond to tokenization requests, without the analysis required under the Paperwork Reduction Act.
Oversight and operational concerns
Under the SEC order, tokenized securities venues may begin operations after posting a notice of intent on their website and providing notice of registration to the Commission roughly 30 days later.
No affirmative approval by the SEC or FINRA is required, and the framework does not establish threshold due diligence or an ongoing supervisory relationship unless the venue is otherwise registered.
Better Markets argues this replaces a registration-based regime with a disclosure-based one in which venues may disclose the absence of certain procedures, covering complaints, confidentiality, systems safeguards, and surveillance, and still commence trading.
Similar concerns are raised regarding covered firms that provide liquidity through automated market-maker pools. These firms are not subject to SEC or FINRA registration or reporting requirements, a limitation the letter says will be difficult to enforce without baseline oversight.
Market structure and investor protection issues
Better Markets argues that the exemption could increase market fragmentation because the new venues would not be required to communicate prices with one another or ensure investors receive the national best bid and offer.
The letter also points to the SEC’s separate consideration of amendments to Rule 611, known as the Order Protection Rule. It notes that automated market maker pools may be unable to comply with existing trade-through requirements and questions whether the Commission is considering the interaction between the two regulatory changes.
On investor protection, Better Markets highlights the order’s reliance on self-custody for retail participants and the associated risks of loss, theft, or operational failure. It references known cybersecurity vulnerabilities in decentralized finance, including smart-contract exploits and bridge attacks, and questions the transfer of those risks into the trading of NMS stocks.
The letter raises further questions about trading pairs involving tokenized NMS stocks and non-security crypto assets. While the SEC order identifies payment stablecoins issued by permitted payment stablecoin issuers as an example, Better Markets argues that it does not clearly establish the legal basis for allowing other non-security assets, including algorithmic stablecoins and Bitcoin, to trade alongside securities on these venues.
The group also questions the obligations placed on public companies whose shares may be tokenized by unaffiliated parties, including how issuers can monitor such activity and object to tokenization requests.
Better Markets urged the SEC to withdraw the exemption, conduct the required legal and economic analyses, and propose any changes to the trading of NMS stocks or their tokenized equivalents through formal rulemaking under the APA.
Also Read: Uniswap v4 Adds Seven External Liquidity Sources Through Aggregator Hooks
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


