Better Markets Says Binance Hack Exposes Gaps in US Crypto Regulation
Key Highlights
- Better Markets said the reported $6.3 billion Binance hack highlights weaknesses in crypto security and the ability to trace and recover stolen assets.
- The group argued that the proposed CLARITY Act would not have prevented the incident and could preserve gaps involving decentralised platforms and crypto mixers.
- It said the GENIUS Act does not provide sufficient protection for customers affected by hacks or establish a clear mechanism for returning frozen assets.
Investor advocacy group Better Markets has argued that the reported $6.3 billion Binance hack exposes gaps in US crypto regulation, including weaknesses in customer protection, cybersecurity oversight and the recovery of stolen digital assets.
In an October 30 article published in its Substack newsletter, The Public Interest, Amanda Fischer, chief operating officer and policy director at Better Markets, said the incident raised questions about the regulatory approach to the cryptocurrency industry.
Fischer criticised the CLARITY Act and the GENIUS Act, arguing that neither provides sufficient safeguards against large-scale hacks or the movement of stolen funds.
Fischer says crypto’s structure can make stolen funds harder to recover
Fischer acknowledged that cyberattacks affect financial institutions across the industry but argued that certain characteristics of cryptocurrency can make stolen funds easier to move and conceal.
She pointed to the pseudonymous nature of blockchain transactions, the availability of mixers and other services that obscure transaction links, and the ability to trade and transfer crypto assets around the clock.
According to Fischer, criminals assess not only whether they can breach a platform but also how easily they can move stolen assets afterwards. She argued that crypto’s continuous trading environment and services designed to obscure transaction trails can make laundering stolen funds more efficient than moving illicit money through traditional financial channels.
Binance hack response shows challenges of tracking funds across DeFi
Recent developments following the Binance breach illustrate some of the challenges Fischer raised about restricting stolen assets.
In a report on the incident, The Crypto Times detailed how wallets linked to the Binance hot wallet outflow used Aave to borrow approximately $44.6 million in Ether against $60 million in USDT. The activity allowed the attacker to move into an asset that could not be frozen through the same stablecoin controls.
A subsequent report said Aave restricted new deposits and borrowing across most of its markets after the activity was identified. Another report covered emergency restrictions across 16 networks, including Aave’s Avalanche markets, alongside Arbitrum’s seizure of $30.5 million in assets linked to the exploit.
The Crypto Times also reported that Binance said approximately $3 billion in affected assets had been frozen and that the exchange would cover the losses.
These figures reflect actions reported at different stages of the response, not a final accounting of recovered funds. Frozen assets have not necessarily been returned to affected users.
Better Markets argues CLARITY Act would not have prevented the Binance hack
Fischer said the proposed CLARITY Act would not have prevented the Binance incident, even if the relevant activity had taken place in the United States.
She argued that the legislation maintains gaps in the oversight of decentralised crypto platforms and does not provide a clear regulatory framework for mixers, which can make it harder to trace the movement of stolen funds.
Fischer also criticised the business structure of crypto exchanges, arguing that platforms often combine exchange, brokerage and custody functions. Under this model, a single platform may hold customer assets while also operating the trading venue. She said this concentration can make large exchanges attractive targets because substantial amounts of customer funds are held within the same infrastructure.
She compared this structure with traditional securities markets, where brokers connect customers to exchanges and may obtain protection through the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). In her view, separating brokerage and exchange functions can limit the impact of an attack on a single intermediary, while crypto customers do not receive equivalent protection under the proposed legislation.
Fischer also questioned whether the proposed requirement for exchanges to maintain a contingency equivalent to one year’s operating expenses would be sufficient to address losses on the scale of the Binance breach.
These points reflect Better Markets’ assessment of the proposed legislation rather than a finding that the Act would necessarily leave every type of crypto business without oversight.
Fischer says GENIUS Act does not provide sufficient customer protection
Fischer also criticised the GENIUS Act, which establishes a federal framework for payment stablecoins.
She argued that the legislation does not provide an effective mechanism for protecting customers when stablecoins are involved in a hack. In particular, she questioned whether its requirements for freezing assets would allow issuers to act quickly enough to prevent stolen funds from being moved through other services.
According to Fischer, the Act requires stablecoin issuers to freeze assets pursuant to a court order under its framework. She argued that waiting for such an order could be too slow to stop criminals from transferring or laundering stolen funds.
Fischer also argued that the Act does not require issuers to return frozen assets to their rightful owners or provide direct protection to customers whose funds are stolen. She contrasted this with the Binance response, in which stablecoin issuers reportedly made independent decisions to restrict assets linked to suspected attacker wallets.
Her criticism centres on the absence of a clear recovery process. The statutory requirements and issuers’ responses during the Binance incident are separate matters.
Better Markets questions crypto’s role in the regulated financial system
Fischer argued that the Binance incident raises broader questions about whether permissionless blockchain systems are suitable for integration into the regulated financial system.
She said pseudonymous transactions, continuous trading and services that obscure fund movements create risks that traditional financial safeguards may not fully address.
“Crypto doesn’t belong in the regulated financial system,” Fischer wrote, arguing that open blockchain networks remain particularly vulnerable to theft and the rapid movement of stolen assets.
She also warned against bringing crypto activities into the taxpayer-backed banking system without stronger safeguards for customers and financial institutions.
These are Better Markets’ policy positions. Fischer’s article does not establish that all blockchain networks or crypto businesses carry the same risks, or that the Binance incident alone determines whether digital assets should be integrated into traditional finance.
Fischer criticises CFTC’s legal action against Utah
Fischer also criticised the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) for suing Utah over the state’s restrictions on prediction market platforms offering contracts tied to sporting events.
She noted that the lawsuit was filed on the same day as the Binance hack. Utah has a history of prohibiting gambling, and Governor Spencer Cox had described Kalshi as the “manager of a back-alley gambling den,” according to Fischer’s article.
The Better Markets policy director argued that the regulator should prioritise cybersecurity and customer protection rather than using its legal resources to challenge state restrictions on sports-related event contracts.
“Whatever you think of nationwide sports gambling, it’s clear that time at the CFTC would be better spent ensuring U.S. customers weren’t affected by the Binance hack, bolstering cyber defenses at crypto firms, and helping law enforcement trace the path of stolen funds,” Fischer wrote.
Her comments reflect the group’s position on the CFTC’s priorities. The lawsuit concerns the regulator’s authority over prediction markets and Utah’s restrictions, rather than the investigation into the Binance breach.
Better markets calls for stronger customer safeguards
Fischer proposed faster asset freezes, circuit-breakers that can stop unusually large withdrawals from exchanges and stronger insurance protection for crypto customers, arguing that these measures could reduce losses during major security incidents.
She said such measures would bring elements of established financial safeguards into the crypto industry, whose regulatory and operating structures differ from those of traditional financial markets.
“Rather than continuing to learn this lesson the hard way, we should return to first principles and import over longstanding frameworks that have protected investors for decades,” Fischer wrote.
Also Read: Binance’s $6.3B Hack: What Teng Revealed About the Attack and Recovery
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


