CFTC Sues Utah to Defend Federal Oversight of Prediction Markets
CFTC lawsuit aims to keep prediction markets open, protecting multi‑billion‑dollar trading volumes from state bans.
Utah seeks to seize Kalshi’s profits and reimburse users, potentially costing the platform millions.
Federal challenge signals broader market uncertainty as nine states face similar legal pressure on derivatives trading.
The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has sued Utah to prevent the state from using its laws to restrict federally registered prediction markets.
The lawsuit, filed on October 26, follows Utah’s case against Kalshi and adds to a growing dispute over whether federal or state authorities have jurisdiction over platforms that let users trade contracts based on future events.
In an official release on Tuesday, the CFTC said Utah’s actions interfere with federal law, which the agency argues gives it exclusive authority over federally registered contract markets. The commission is seeking to prevent the state from blocking these platforms from operating while the legal dispute over their contracts continues. “Utah seeks to shut down prediction markets across a wide variety of markets,” CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig said.
Selig said prediction markets provide more than a way to invest or manage financial risks, arguing that they can also help the public assess the likelihood of future events. He said Congress had trusted the CFTC with overseeing these markets and that the agency would defend its authority over commodity derivatives.
Utah takes Kalshi to court over alleged gambling
The lawsuit comes days after Utah took legal action against prediction market platform Kalshi.
On October 20, 2026, Utah Attorney General Derek Brown announced that the state was seeking to block Kalshi’s sports, political, election and cultural markets, accusing the company of offering illegal online gambling.
Utah is asking the court to halt the targeted markets, recover profits earned from users in the state and order payments to affected customers. The case also names two Susquehanna trading firms, marking the first legal action against prediction market makers. The state is also asking the court to approve a geolocation provider to help prevent people in the state from accessing the markets.
Brown said the state decided to act because it believed the platform was harming residents. “Under Utah law, I have determined that this operation is causing a significant and substantial ongoing harm to a significant number of Utahns,” he said. He added that the state wants the defendants to “give up the profits that they have made, to pay restitution, and to be accountable for the public nuisance that they have caused here in the state of Utah.”
The legal dispute extends beyond Utah
The CFTC said its lawsuit is part of a broader effort to defend the authority Congress granted it over federally registered prediction markets. The agency has also initiated legal proceedings against nine other states and submitted briefs in four federal courts of appeal and one state supreme court.
Meanwhile, the Coalition for Prediction Markets has backed a federal framework for the industry. In a July 27 comment letter, the coalition supported reviewing event contracts one by one instead of automatically banning entire categories. However, it also asked the CFTC to revise parts of its proposed rules, including the meaning of “gaming” and how certain contracts are reviewed.
The dispute centers on whether federally registered prediction markets can operate under federal oversight or face restrictions under state gambling laws. The CFTC’s lawsuit seeks to challenge Utah’s efforts to restrict these platforms, while the state continues its case against Kalshi.
Also Read: Coinbase to Convert 14 Crypto Assets for EEA Customers Under MiCA
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


