Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward Lead 6-Firm Amicus Backing CFTC on Equity Perps

Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward Lead 6-Firm Amicus Backing CFTC on Equity Perps


Coinbase, Kalshi, Kraken parent Payward, and three major trading and investment firms have filed a proposed amicus brief supporting the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in a legal fight over perpetual futures tied to individual stocks.

In the November 9 filing in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York, Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading, and Paradigm Operations sought permission to submit arguments backing the CFTC’s opposition to a preliminary injunction brought by the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA). Their 36-page brief argues that equity perpetuals qualify as security futures under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA), rather than security-based swaps that would fall under the SEC’s framework.

May 2026: CFTC approved KalshiEX Bitcoin perpetuals, prompting expansion to single-stock contracts.

Nov 2-3, 2024: CFTC approved applications; Kalshi launched stock perps on Nov 5; Judge denied CMAA restraining order on Nov 3.

Nov 9, 2024: Six firms filed amicus supporting CFTC; SEC sought to file its own brief, continuing the legal timeline.

An amicus brief, from the Latin amicus curiae, or “friend of the court,” is a filing submitted by someone who is not a party to a lawsuit but has a stake in its outcome, offering the judge arguments or context the named parties might not fully cover. It carries no binding weight and usually requires the court’s permission to file. Here, the six firms are neither suing nor being sued; they are urging the court to side with the CFTC.

The timing underscores the obstacle the firms face. In denying CMAA’s earlier emergency request, the judge found the association was likely to succeed on its central statutory argument — refusing to halt trading only because CMAA had not shown imminent, irreparable harm.

What Equity Perpetuals Are and How They Reached US Markets

Perpetual futures, commonly called perps, are derivative contracts that let traders take long or short positions on an asset without owning it. Unlike conventional futures, they carry no fixed expiration date. A funding-payment mechanism keeps a perpetual’s price aligned with its underlying asset, so traders can hold a position without periodically closing it or rolling into a new contract, though margin requirements and other exchange rules still apply.

The product has been widely used in offshore cryptocurrency markets, and the brief frames perps as an established global derivatives market that US traders should be able to access through regulated domestic exchanges.

The US regulatory push began with crypto. In May 2026, the CFTC approved KalshiEX’s Bitcoin perpetual futures contract, BTCPERP, as a futures product. The agencies then moved to extend the framework to individual stocks. On November 3, CFTC Chairman Michael Selig said perpetual futures tied to individual equity securities could begin trading on qualifying CFTC-registered exchanges that are also notice-registered with the SEC as national securities exchanges, and the CFTC said the products would operate under the joint regulatory framework for security futures.

The listings themselves moved faster than the litigation. Coinbase Derivatives, KalshiEX, and Bitnomial submitted their single-stock perpetual applications in September; the applications were deemed approved on November 2 after the CFTC did not act within the applicable review period. Kalshi launched its single-stock perpetuals on November 5, initially offering exposure to more than 50 major US-listed companies.

Those contracts do not convey ownership of the underlying shares. Notably, Kalshi’s product documentation specifies that its stock perpetuals follow set trading schedules rather than running 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and that they can involve leverage, funding payments and liquidation risk.

CMAA sued the CFTC and Chairman Selig on November 2, arguing that equity perpetuals should be classified as security-based swaps rather than security futures. The distinction decides which regulator is in charge: security futures sit under a joint CFTC-SEC framework, while security-based swaps are primarily the SEC’s domain. CMAA contends that perpetual contracts without fixed expiration dates do not meet the statutory definition of security futures, and that the CFTC exceeded its authority by letting the products trade under that label.

The association first sought a temporary restraining order to stop the contracts from trading. On November 3, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied that request, but her order carried a pointed warning for the CFTC. The judge wrote that CMAA was likely to succeed on its claim that the agency lacked statutory authority to allow single-stock perpetuals to be offered to retail investors on CFTC-regulated platforms. The contracts, she said, did not appear to meet the definition of a security future, because they did not provide for the sale of a single security for future delivery, and they appeared instead to meet the definition of swaps, which fall under SEC regulation.

Even so, the court denied the restraining order because CMAA had not shown that its members faced imminent, irreparable harm without emergency relief. The November 3 order therefore let trading continue while the broader preliminary-injunction dispute played out; it was not a ruling that the CFTC’s interpretation was correct.

How the Six Firms Defend the CFTC’s Position

The six proposed amici argue that CMAA is asking the wrong statutory question. Their central point is that the CEA defines a security future as a contract of sale for future delivery of a single security, and that equity perpetuals fit: each references an individual stock and provides cash settlement when a position is closed. The contracts also share the core characteristics of traditional futures, they say — exchange-traded, centrally cleared, fungible, cash-settled, and traded on margin.

The firms’ main disagreement with CMAA is over the missing expiration date. The CEA, they argue, requires delivery in the future but does not expressly require a specific future date, so a contract does not stop being a future simply because it has no scheduled expiry. They further contend that security futures are subject to joint CFTC-SEC oversight under the framework established by the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000, and that the SEC was never cut out of the process, pointing to the agencies’ joint work, the exchanges’ SEC registrations, and the SEC’s authority to review or abrogate the relevant exchange filings.

The submission is an interested-party brief. Coinbase, Kalshi, and Bitnomial have direct commercial stakes because they pursued the underlying listings, while DRW, Jump and Paradigm say they participate in, or are exploring participation in, the equity-perpetuals market.

The SEC Also Seeks to Enter the Case

A further development came on November 9, when the SEC separately moved for permission to file its own amicus brief. That is significant because the dispute turns on the division of authority between the securities and derivatives regulators, though the SEC’s position should not be read into its request to participate, and the substance of its proposed brief was not clear from the available filings.

The CFTC had already filed its opposition to CMAA’s preliminary-injunction request on November 6, with CMAA’s reply due November 10 under the court’s briefing schedule.

Why the Dispute Matters for Crypto

The case could shape whether a derivatives structure that rose to prominence in crypto markets can expand into US-regulated equity markets. For crypto exchanges, the outcome may set the regulatory path for perpetual futures beyond Bitcoin and other digital assets: Coinbase and Payward have interests in expanding regulated derivatives offerings, and Kalshi has already introduced stock-linked perpetuals.

The six firms argue that blocking the products would simply push trading back to offshore venues, where US regulators have less direct oversight. CMAA counters that the contracts fall outside the CFTC’s statutory authority and raise concerns about market integrity and regulatory jurisdiction.

The fight is part of a broader challenge to how the CFTC treats perpetual futures. The Chicago Mercantile Exchange separately sued the agency in June over its classification of Bitcoin perpetual contracts as futures, arguing it had overstepped; that case is pending in the US District Court for the District of Columbia.

The immediate question is whether the court will grant CMAA’s preliminary injunction. The November 3 order has already cast doubt on the CFTC’s statutory interpretation, while the new filings hand the court arguments from firms seeking to preserve the products. For now, no final ruling has established whether single-stock perpetuals can legally remain under the security-futures framework.

Also Read: Binance, Tether, Trump Crypto Firms Face Blumenthal’s Jan 4 Records Deadline


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *