Digital Chamber Urges SEC to Recognize Blockchain Ownership Records

Digital Chamber Urges SEC to Recognize Blockchain Ownership Records


Key Highlights

The Digital Chamber has urged the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to make its proposed transfer-agent rules more accommodating of blockchain-based securities recordkeeping, arguing that the framework should not favor traditional databases or privately controlled networks.

In a November 3 comment letter submitted through Morrison & Foerster LLP, the industry group supported modernizing transfer-agent requirements but raised concerns that certain provisions could restrict blockchain-based recordkeeping and limit competition.

The comments respond to the SEC’s proposed amendments to its transfer-agent rules, published in September under Release No. 34-106246. The proposal addresses master securityholder files (MSFs), electronic recordkeeping practices and activities involving tokenized securities.

The Digital Chamber, which represents more than 250 companies across the digital asset industry, outlined eight recommendations for the commission to consider before adopting the final rules.

SEC’s tokenization rules remain under discussion

The Digital Chamber’s recommendations come amid broader discussions about how securities regulations should apply to blockchain-based markets.

In September, the SEC granted a five-year exemption for certain tokenized stock trading arrangements involving national market system stocks and public permissionless blockchains. The exemption provides a limited route for eligible venues to operate under specified conditions while the commission considers its longer-term approach. 

The commission’s work has also addressed crypto governance and market structure. On November 3, SEC staff issued FAQs on governance and decentralization, while Broadridge, Computershare, Equiniti and Superstate joined the planned NYSE-affiliated tokenized securities venue alongside Securitize and tZERO. 

Questions about how securities laws apply to decentralized finance have also reached the SEC. On November 3, Aave, Kamino and Veda submitted recommendations on DeFi lending, arguing that users retain control of their assets and that protocols do not promise repayment. 

Digital Chamber wants blockchain to serve as the official ownership record

The group asked the SEC to explicitly recognize that a distributed ledger can serve as all or part of a transfer agent’s official MSF.

Under the proposed rules, a transfer agent would be required to maintain an electronic MSF and retain exclusive control over it. The SEC has acknowledged that blockchain could be used for this purpose but has sought feedback on whether additional conditions should apply.

The Digital Chamber said exclusive control should refer to a transfer agent’s legal authority and procedures for managing the official ownership record, rather than ownership or operation of the blockchain network. This would allow transfer agents to use public blockchains without controlling their validators, nodes or consensus mechanisms, while retaining the authority to correct errors, reconcile positions and make records available for regulatory examination.

In its letter, the group said the rules should recognize that an on-chain ledger may constitute the official MSF “without a separate authoritative off-chain replication solely because a distributed ledger is used.”

It also recommended hybrid recordkeeping systems in which token balances, wallet identifiers and transaction histories remain on-chain, while personal information such as names and tax details is stored in a linked off-chain system. According to the group, this approach would link ownership data with securityholder information without requiring two separate authoritative ledgers.

Group seeks flexibility for multiple transfer agents

The Digital Chamber also opposed the SEC’s proposal that only one recordkeeping transfer agent may maintain and update the MSF for a particular securities issue.

It wants issuers to be able to choose between different arrangements, including lead and sub-transfer-agent structures or multiple agents maintaining separate authoritative portions of the same ownership record.

For example, one transfer agent could maintain conventional book-entry positions while another handles tokenized positions for the same securities issue. Separate agents could also maintain records for positions represented on different blockchains.

Under a lead-agent structure, one transfer agent would coordinate the overall ownership record and reconcile share counts, while other registered agents would manage specific parts of the record.

A co-equal structure could allow multiple registered agents to maintain their assigned portions of the official MSF, with those records collectively forming the complete ownership record.

The group said each transfer agent should remain responsible for the records and functions it manages, with the participating agents ensuring that the combined records remain accurate, reconciled and accessible to regulators.

Digital Chamber opposes proposed Section 5 requirement

The letter also challenges proposed Rule 17Ad-31(b), which would introduce a new gatekeeping obligation for registered transfer agents.

The provision would prohibit a transfer agent from facilitating certain unregistered securities transactions unless it has a reasonable basis to believe that the transaction does not violate Section 5(a) of the Securities Act of 1933.

The SEC’s proposal includes examples such as initial unregistered securities issuances, the removal of restrictive legends and certain transactions involving company affiliates, officers or directors.

The Digital Chamber said the requirement could force transfer agents to assess transactions beyond their usual recordkeeping responsibilities. Transfer agents generally maintain ownership records and process changes in registered ownership, but they may not have access to information about every transaction involving a security.

This could be particularly challenging when securities are held through intermediaries or tokenized interests are traded separately from the underlying securities.

The group argued that the requirement could lead to additional legal reviews, higher costs and delays, particularly for automated transactions. It therefore asked the SEC not to adopt the provision.

If the commission proceeds, the Digital Chamber recommended replacing the reasonable-basis test with an actual-knowledge standard. Under this approach, a transfer agent would be restricted from processing a requested action only when it actually knows that the action would facilitate a transaction violating Section 5(a).

The group argued that transfer agents should not be independently required to investigate transactions or trace related dealings to identify potential violations of Section 5.

The Digital Chamber asked the SEC to permit reliable electronic communication methods instead of requiring every registered securityholder to provide a physical mailing address.

The proposed rules would require a securityholder’s contact information to include at least a physical mailing address. The group argued that the requirement should prioritize identifying securityholders and ensuring they can receive issuer communications and payments, rather than mandating a specific contact method.

It recommended allowing verified electronic or wallet-linked communication methods, provided they include safeguards for delivery, record retention and contingency arrangements. However, it cautioned that wallet addresses should not automatically be treated as equivalent to physical addresses because their ability to support shareholder communications and other functions is still developing.

The group also addressed how transfer agents should provide records for regulatory examination. It said the SEC should permit regulators to access records directly through blockchain systems without requiring a separate authoritative off-chain database solely for examination purposes.

It further argued that transfer agents should not have to operate their own blockchain nodes or enter into agreements with unrelated validators and open-source developers simply because they use decentralized networks.

The letter also asked the SEC to clarify how record correction and retention requirements would apply to immutable blockchains, where earlier transactions cannot be physically deleted.

SEC asked to protect issuer choice and competition

The letter raised concerns that the proposed rules could make it harder for issuers to change transfer agents or for smaller service providers to compete.

The SEC proposal would require specified records to be made available to an issuer or its designated successor within 15 calendar days after a transfer agent stops performing its functions for an issue.

The Digital Chamber supported timely access but asked the commission to clarify how the requirement would apply to on-chain information, linked off-chain data and pending transactions.

It argued that contractual, technical or licensing restrictions should not prevent the transfer of usable records to a successor agent.

The group also addressed the SEC’s proposed amendments to Form TA-2, which would collect information about tokenized securities activities and service providers.

It asked the commission to clarify reporting categories for tokenization agents and distributed ledger technology platforms, particularly for hybrid arrangements involving multiple networks or transfer agents. The group said reporting requirements should help the SEC understand the market without favoring any particular blockchain network or centralized recordkeeping model.

The group urged the SEC to ensure the final rules protect the accuracy and accessibility of securities ownership records while allowing issuers and transfer agents to choose their recordkeeping technology and service providers.

The SEC has not yet issued a final rule responding to the recommendations in the November 3 submission.

Also Read: Coinbase Brings Deribit Liquidity to US Institutions via Prime


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.







Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *