Patrick McHenry Says Crypto ‘Blew It’ on CLARITY Act

Patrick McHenry Says Crypto ‘Blew It’ on CLARITY Act


Former House Financial Services Committee Chairman Patrick McHenry has blamed the crypto industry’s push for a more comprehensive market-structure bill for the failure to advance the CLARITY Act in the Senate, saying the industry “blew it” by holding out for what he described as an unattainable version of the legislation.

McHenry made the remarks in comments reported by journalist Eleanor Terrett following his appearance on Bloomberg TV. In a subsequent interview with Terrett, he discussed the negotiations behind the bill, the decisions made by industry participants and the political obstacles that prevented it from moving forward.

A post‑midterm session could revive the CLARITY Act, but only if bipartisan ethics compromises are reached.

If Congress stalls, the SEC and CFTC will rely on existing authority, offering limited regulatory certainty for crypto firms.

Industry’s demand for perfect legislation may prompt future narrower bills, reshaping crypto regulatory strategy.

His assessment comes after the Senate failed to invoke cloture on a motion to proceed to the CLARITY Act on September 15, leaving the legislation short of the support needed to advance.

‘A Crypto Coalition That Blew It’

McHenry’s central criticism was that parts of the crypto industry sought a more ambitious version of the legislation instead of accepting a compromise that could have moved through Congress.

“Frankly, you had a crypto coalition that blew it,” he said. “They had an opportunity to legislate, and they were holding out for something that was unattainable, a perfect piece of legislation. And rather than take something that was good, many of them held out for perfection, and now have ended up with nothing legislatively.”

In his longer conversation with Terrett, McHenry also acknowledged that he shared some responsibility for the outcome and reflected on decisions made during the legislative process.

One issue he discussed was the decision to pursue stablecoin legislation and broader crypto market-structure legislation as separate efforts. The stablecoin-focused GENIUS Act became law in 2025, while the CLARITY Act remained unresolved.

The two bills addressed different parts of the regulatory framework. The GENIUS Act established a federal framework for payment stablecoins, while the CLARITY Act sought to establish rules for digital-asset markets and divide regulatory responsibilities between the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

McHenry Says CLARITY Was ‘Only Part of the Story’

McHenry also argued that the CLARITY Act’s failure should not overshadow what he considers broader bipartisan progress on crypto policy.

“CLARITY is only part of the story,” he wrote on X, pointing to what he described as significant progress compared with the state of crypto policy two and four years earlier. He attributed the breakdown in negotiations partly to the election-year political environment, arguing that lawmakers had reached a point where no compromise would satisfy all sides.

“On CLARITY the fact is that we got to September where nothing would ever be good enough because you’re in a political cycle,” McHenry wrote. He also argued that Democrats walked away from what he considered an “excellent compromise.”

That is McHenry’s interpretation of the negotiations, rather than an agreed explanation for the bill’s failure.

Democratic lawmakers raised objections over ethics provisions and potential conflicts of interest involving public officials’ financial interests in crypto businesses. Several Democrats argued that the legislation needed stronger safeguards addressing those concerns, including matters connected to President Donald Trump and his family’s crypto-related business interests. Democratic negotiators had submitted a counterproposal hours before the September 15 vote, seeking stronger restrictions on officials issuing or sponsoring digital assets, divestment requirements and a greater enforcement role for state attorneys general. 

The disagreement remained a significant point of contention even after Republican lawmakers released revised legislative language. On September 14, 2026, Senate Banking Committee leaders said the final draft incorporated 126 substantive changes requested by Democrats and included revised ethics language. The revised text did not secure enough support to advance the following day.

How the CLARITY Act Stalled in Congress

The Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, or CLARITY Act, passed the House of Representatives on July 17, 2025, by a vote of 294-134. The measure received support from 78 Democrats alongside Republicans.

The legislation sought to establish a regulatory framework for digital assets, including a division of responsibilities between the SEC and CFTC. Its supporters argued that clearer rules would help define which digital assets fall under securities or commodities oversight and provide greater certainty for crypto businesses.

The bill subsequently faced a more difficult path in the Senate. On September 15, 2026, senators voted on whether to invoke cloture on a motion to proceed to H.R. 3633, the CLARITY Act. The motion failed by 49 votes to 50, short of the 60 votes required.

The distinction is important: the Senate did not hold a final passage vote on the CLARITY Act. It rejected the procedural motion needed to move forward with consideration of the bill. The Senate’s official roll-call record records the outcome as “Cloture on the Motion to Proceed Rejected.”

The September vote followed months of negotiations over the legislation’s scope and provisions. Republican sponsors released a revised draft on September 14, saying it reflected changes requested by Democrats, including new ethics language and additional enforcement provisions. Those revisions did not produce the support needed to proceed.

What Comes Next for Crypto Regulation?

With the Senate motion to proceed rejected, the CLARITY Act has not become law. Its future depends on whether lawmakers return to the legislation and can reach an agreement on the issues that divided them.

McHenry had previously argued that a post-midterm lame-duck session could offer another opportunity to advance the bill. In an October 2 appearance on CoinDesk’s The Policy Protocol, he said the legislation could still move during that period, after the election-year political cycle had passed. The interview also addressed whether lawmakers should pursue narrower crypto bills rather than a broader market-structure package.

The 2026 midterm elections have now taken place, but the outcome of the CLARITY Act negotiations remains unresolved. Any further legislative effort would need to account for the composition and priorities of the incoming Congress, as well as the outstanding disagreements over ethics and regulatory oversight.

In the meantime, the SEC and CFTC can continue to address digital-asset issues within their existing statutory authorities. However, agency guidance and rulemaking would not necessarily provide the same statutory clarity or durability as legislation establishing a market-structure framework.

McHenry’s criticism also comes from a perspective shaped by his post-Congress career. Since leaving the House in January 2025, he has taken on advisory roles, including as a senior adviser at venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), according to the firm’s official biography. His views therefore reflect both his experience negotiating crypto legislation in Congress and his current involvement in the financial and technology sectors.

The debate over the CLARITY Act now extends beyond whether the industry should have accepted an earlier compromise. It also raises questions about how lawmakers can reconcile market-structure rules with ethics safeguards and whether a broader bipartisan agreement remains possible.

Also Read: Coinbase VP Says More Democrats Want Clearer Crypto Rules


Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *