Polymarket Fires CMO Modabber Over Staged-Trading Scandal
Polymarket, a major crypto-native prediction market, has fired a member of its senior leadership in a shake-up that reaches into the inner circle of its founder Shayne Coplan. According to a New York Post report published October 22, citing sources, the company dismissed Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) Matthew Modabber, a longtime confidant of CEO Shayne Coplan, following an internal investigation into a controversial influencer-marketing campaign.
The report did not publicly detail the investigation’s findings. Polymarket declined to comment, and Modabber did not respond to requests for comment.
Modabber joined Polymarket in January 2024 as one of its early executives and built its marketing operation into a team of more than 50 people, according to the report. The company had reportedly restructured the department in August and reduced his responsibilities before his dismissal. The New York Post reported that the board backed the move and that Coplan had initially resisted it before accepting the decision. The report also said the two sides were finalizing a separation agreement.
CEO Shayne Coplan accepted board‑backed dismissal of CMO Matthew Modabber after influencer‑marketing probe.
Modabber allegedly paid over $2.5 million to 800+ creators via his PayPal, funding the controversial campaign.
Senators Adam Schiff and John Curtis urged CFTC investigation, while a consumer‑advocates lawsuit named Coplan, Modabber, Polymarket.
The Campaign at the Center of It
Polymarket is a prediction market, a venue where users trade contracts on the outcome of real-world events, from elections to sports, with trading conducted in USDC on the Polygon blockchain. The controversy concerns how it was marketed.
According to a June 2026 investigation, paid creators published roughly 1,105 promotional videos between December 2025 and May 2026. Reportedly hundreds of the videos were filmed on replica websites built to look like Polymarket’s real platform. The videos reportedly depicted about $1.9 million in simulated wagers, with 118 clips showing close to $900,000 in purported winnings. An analysis found that the corresponding wagers, if placed on the actual platform, would have lost more than $166,000.
The campaign reportedly drew more than 140 million views across TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube. Reportedly, some creators failed to disclose their financial ties and that some clips used outdated footage or altered headlines to present losing positions as profitable.
The money trail is part of the story. Modabber’s personal PayPal account reportedly paid creators more than $2.5 million across more than 800 recipients between January 2025 and February 2026, including at least $350,000 to identified influencers. The payments were reportedly routed through an account tied to a separate business he co-founded. Company lawyers reportedly raised concerns about the simulated-trading campaign and told him to stop it before the story became public in June.
The available reporting does not establish that Modabber personally directed every video or that every payment was connected to the alleged staged-trading practices. The findings of the company’s internal investigation have not been publicly detailed.
Regulators and a Lawsuit Are Circling
The marketing campaign has drawn scrutiny beyond the company. Senators Adam Schiff and John Curtis pressed the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to investigate the advertising.
Separately, the National Association of Consumer Advocates filed a lawsuit in Washington, D.C., on June 26 naming Polymarket, Coplan, and Modabber, among others. The complaint alleges deceptive advertising, undisclosed paid endorsements, staged wagers, and marketing aimed at college-aged consumers. Those claims remain unresolved and should not be treated as established violations of law.
Why the Timing Matters
The reported departure comes as Polymarket pursues institutional relationships and expands its presence in the US prediction-market sector.
Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the parent company of the New York Stock Exchange, announced a strategic investment of up to $2 billion in Polymarket in October 2025. ICE subsequently announced a further $600 million direct investment in March 2026. The deal was reported at a valuation of around $9 billion.
Further, Polymarket and rival Kalshi have reportedly explored raising capital at higher valuations. The company has also been relaunching in the United States through a CFTC-regulated structure following its acquisition of a licensed exchange. Additionally, widely circulating reports that Polymarket is considering a public listing as soon as 2027 should be treated as potential plans, not a confirmed IPO timeline.
That trajectory helps explain why the marketing allegations matter. A company attracting institutional investment and operating in a regulated market faces scrutiny over whether its advertising accurately represents its platform and trading outcomes. The reported dismissal is a leadership development, but it does not by itself establish that the company has resolved the concerns raised in June 2026.
What the Case Means for Prediction Markets
The episode highlights the importance of transparent advertising as prediction markets attract a wider audience. Promotional content that presents simulated wagers as real trades can mislead viewers about platform activity, potential returns and the risks of financial loss.
For companies operating in regulated markets, clear sponsorship disclosures, authentic trading demonstrations, and controls over third-party marketing are important parts of consumer protection. Whether the conduct alleged in Polymarket’s case violated applicable laws will depend on the evidence and the outcome of the relevant legal or regulatory processes.
For now, the central allegations remain unproven, and The Crypto Times does not forecast the outcome of the investigation or the company’s plans.
Also Read: Kalshi and BitGo Launch Crypto-Backed Loans for Futures Margin
Disclaimer: The information researched and reported by The Crypto Times is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional financial advice. Investing in crypto assets involves significant risk due to market volatility. Always Do Your Own Research (DYOR) and consult with a qualified Financial Advisor before making any investment decisions.


